Two Earl Greys can make very different everyday teas. One may suit you plain; another may be the one you reach for with milk. Before choosing by a handsome tin or a word such as “supreme,” check three things: the tea base, how the citrus flavor is described, and anything else added to the blend.
This is a guide to choosing what to try. The examples are drawn from makers’ ingredient lists, not our own side-by-side tasting. They show why the product details are more useful than treating every Earl Grey as the same recipe.
Start with the tea base
Black tea with bergamot is the familiar starting point, but a blend can contain more than black tea. Harney & Sons Earl Grey Supreme, for example, lists black teas alongside oolong, white tea and oil of bergamot. That is a specific recipe, not a rule for every product carrying the Earl Grey name.
Look for enough detail to understand what you are buying. Does the description name the tea types? Does it identify origins, or simply say black tea? Either can be an acceptable everyday purchase, but they give you different amounts of information to compare. If you already know you prefer a particular tea base, make that your first filter.
Do not read a decorative grade word as a promise that you will like the cup more. A longer ingredient list, a larger leaf or a more expensive tin cannot settle a preference for you. Use the description to build a shortlist, then taste.
Read the flavor description and the extras
Harney’s example explicitly names bergamot oil. Another label may describe its flavoring more broadly. If the source of the flavor matters to you and the wording is unclear, ask the maker rather than filling in the missing detail yourself. A named oil also does not tell you how intense the finished tea will taste in your mug.
Related citrus blends can add other ingredients. Twinings Lady Grey lists black tea, orange peel, lemon peel and citrus flavorings. It is a named Twinings blend, not a generic substitute for every Earl Grey recipe. Choose it if those ingredients appeal to you, and compare the current package sold in your market.
| On the label | Ask yourself |
|---|---|
| Tea base | Does this use the tea types I want to drink? |
| Bergamot or flavoring description | Is the detail sufficient for my preferences? |
| Additional ingredients | Do I want those flavors in every cup? |
| Bag, sachet or loose leaf | Does the format fit my equipment and routine? |
| Pack size | Can I try it without committing to a large quantity? |
Try it the way you will drink it
Start with the maker’s recipe. Write down the amount of tea, water volume, temperature and time. Use a clean cup and your usual water source. Smell the brewed cup and taste it once it is comfortable to drink; the fragrance of dry tea alone cannot tell you whether you will enjoy the whole drink.
If you normally add milk, try a small plain taste first and then add your usual measured amount. Record whether the citrus and tea still work together for you. If you want an Earl Grey for a milk-heavy drink, test that drink before buying a bulk bag. A tea you enjoy plain is not automatically your favorite in every preparation.
When a cup seems too assertive, try a modest recipe adjustment on the next brew and change only one variable. If it still does not suit you, choose a different blend. There is no need to turn an everyday purchase into a long project of rescuing a tea you dislike.
Choose a practical format
Loose leaf lets you measure your own dose, while a bag provides a ready portion. Neither format proves the blend will taste better. Read the suggested water volume, particularly if your usual mug is much larger than the serving described. Our infuser comparison can help if you are moving to loose tea.
A focused sampler can be useful here: try a few clearly identified blends and keep the notes with their packets. You are looking for the one you want to brew again, not an abstract winner. Our sampler guide explains what to check before ordering.
Sources and scope
Harney & Sons and Twinings US product pages linked above were checked on 14 November 2026. Examples illustrate label differences; they are not endorsements or a market-wide survey. Check the current pack for ingredients. Artwork depicts a generic tasting setup, not a particular product.
Frequently asked questions
What should I check first when choosing Earl Grey?
Read the tea base, the bergamot or flavoring description, and any additional ingredients. Then choose a format and pack size that fit your routine.
Is every Earl Grey made only with black tea?
No. The Harney Earl Grey Supreme example includes black, oolong and white teas. Read the specific ingredient list rather than assuming a single recipe.
Does a named bergamot oil guarantee a stronger flavor?
No. Naming the ingredient does not tell you its intensity in the brewed cup. Try a small pack using the maker’s directions.
Is Lady Grey the same as Earl Grey?
Lady Grey is a named Twinings blend with additional citrus ingredients, including orange and lemon peel on the US label reviewed here. It is not an interchangeable name for every Earl Grey.
Can I drink Earl Grey with milk?
Try it if that is how you like tea. Taste it plain first, then add your usual measured amount and judge the result for yourself.
Are loose-leaf Earl Greys better than bags?
The format alone cannot establish that. Compare ingredients, dose, preparation and your own preference; bags and loose leaf serve different routines.